I first encountered Elderberry Pond in a restaurant review in Gourmet Magazine in July 2005 and have meant to head there ever since. (And this despite the reviewer’s failure to mention some of my Finger Lakes favorites. ) So, I have finally visited last Saturday night after an adventurous day in Auburn and Skaneateles. An antique dealer in Skaneateles said they were “inconsistent” but. . . . off we went.
Two of us had dinner and. . . Here’s what we ordered for our meal:
***SOUP; Wild Mushroom and Port Wine Bisque; Asparagus/Ramp Soup
***APPETIZER: Bruschetta w/ Fresh Mozzarella & Olive Sun Dried Tomato Tapenade
***MAINS: Duck with Sherry Raisin Sauce; ???? Lamb Chops
***SIDES: Both entrees came with green salads, smashed potatoes, and asparagus
***DESSERTS: Lemon tart and Rhubarb Pie
The soups were both good. The mushroom was a little lighter than the asparagus/ramp in its use of cream but it was not overwhelmed by the port at all. I would have liked a little more ummpph to the asparagus and ramp soup – maybe a bit more ramp? And perhaps soup spoons rather than tablespoons? The tapenade on the bruschetta (which we shared) was very tasty, like all their bread from Essentially Breads in Elbridge. All entrees come with a salad and this was a nice one – mixed greens with a bit of arugula (rocket) that really tasted peppery and along with the radishes (alas, a little cold) and the light dressing made the salad sing. The quality of the meats used for both the lamb and duck entrees was excellent. The lamb chops were recommended at medium, but seemed closer to rare or medium rare. The duck looked a mite overcooked (also recommended at medium) but it was so good that maybe my eyes deceived me. And, the sherry raisin sauce was not-too-sweet and so perfect for the day. Desserts were a bit too cold when they arrived and served with whipped cream – they could have been plated more beautifully to support their lovely tastes. The pastry for the lemon tart got mixed reviews – but the lemon itself was swell. And the rhubarb pie crust was flakey and lovely. Throughout the meal, the portion sizes were reasonable.
WINES: the restaurant has a small but diverse global list, with a few local wines. We chose one of the recommended wines, from Spain: Vinos Nuestra Senora del Portal 2003 at $30. A blend from the Terra Alta region, the wine was imported by a company started by college students:www.oleimports.com. After it breathed a bit, it was a very good choice with our meal.
SERVICE: It was a bit more obtrusive than I would have liked, but friendly.
SETTING: This is a real country place, on a 100 acre wooded site that is an organic farm. It is 30 miles from Geneva and much closer to Skaneateles and Auburn. The owner puts his own photos of the place on his menus. And, there are great windows to look out onto the wooded lot. We were on the porch, which turned out to have good acoustics.
ON THE WALLS: Check out the framed sheet music in the women’s room:”When the Elderberry Blossoms Come in Bloom.”
BATHROOM REVIEW: Two Sheets. There is a women’s room and a men or women’s room. The women’s room has a stall while the uni does not. Nice bits of art on the walls, clean, and welcoming.
EXTRAS: The Elderberry Pond Country Store sells meats, produce and other products. Check out their website for schedule of availability of produce. Alas, we got there at 5:45 and it closed at 5:30, so I can’t review it. Perhaps you can?
MINOR ISSUES: The back of the wine list shows MEN quaffing wine. Wouldn’t it be great to show women too in 2006?
OVERALL: The ingredients were excellent and the setting took me away from home and reminded me of the beauty around us (always a goal). Temperature control might be a bit of an issue – both at the cold end (salads and desserts) and in cooking the meats to the desired point. Cost for two, including wine: $129. Still looking for a bargain and it doesn't beat out our faves that were not in Gourmet. But definitely worth a visit or two.
ALSO REVIEWED AT:
For a recipe adapted from the Elderberry Pond, included in the Gourmet review (July 2005) click here.
Syracuse New Times
Cookin’ in the ‘Cuse (8/ 2005)
WEBSITE: The folks at Elderberry Pond have a site for their restaurant and for their store: www.elderberrypond.com Lovely pictures ! Both restaurant and store also come up on the Local Harvest website – definitely a place to visit virtually.