This book is in airports. It is in real bookstores. It has been on the NY TImes bestseller list. It is in my hand. The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society is a quick read, and I wanted it for some time and then got it as a present. No, it is not a cookbook. No, it is not a murder mystery. It is a swell novel, written in epistolatory form (that means as a series of letters for those of you who don't know; want to pursue more on this? Check out this piece. ). As a set of letters the book is by turns wry, heartbreaking, invigorating, and, overall, it most definitely filled with lovely characters. (The back cover cites some reviews that worry that terms like charming might lead one to think the novel precious. It is not precious; it is, though, warm-hearted. Indeed, I so identified with the protagonist that I too wanted to go to Guernsey and investigate. And I too wanted to be part of the title's literary society -- though I think I might have to be what is called in virtual circles a lurker for quite some time). What is perhaps unsurprising is that, though a society that is fictional, it has its own website.
Among the best lines to open a novel in a while, here's how the book begins:
"Dear Sydney,
Susan Scott is a wonder. We sold over forty copies of the book, which was very pleasant, but much more thrilling from my standpoint was the food. Susan managed to procure ration coupons for icing sugar and real eggs for the meringue." (p. 3)
If you are a sloppy reader as I am, you will have used these sentences to figure out the approximate date and location for the novel's present, something about the protagonist, and several themes of the book. Yes, post-WWII and in the UK. Yes, the letter writer (here the main character among many other swell letter writers, recipients, and persons portrayed in letters), is an author. (Why do I say sloppy reader? Because for much of this information, it would be easier to look at the top of the page where the letter is dated and where the addressee is identified as living in London, but hey, what really sucked me in was the entanglement of food and books. Not to mention meringues.) Hurrah.
So where is Guernsey? Turns out this is what is called a "channel island" and these days their tourist bureau is interested in enticing you (and me). According to their "where we are section of the website" they are 45 minutes by air from London. Put another way, Guernsey is closer to France than England, but loyal to the crown (yep, I swiped that main point from their site though it is evident in teh novel as well). It is self-governing. Once home to Victor Hugo, Guernsey was, according to the novel under review here, occupied by the Nazis in WWII which turns out to be historically accurate. When you google "guernsey nazis," first you get the wikipedia article on the Nazi occupation and then the novel under review here (which tells you they are smart marketers. As an utter side note, or if you really are convinced to explore history by the novel, click here for a occupation era Guernsey newspaper. )
When I imagine WWII and the UK, I think of London blitzes. I did not know (or perhaps had forgotten) that these islands were actually occupied by the Nazis in anticipation of an invasion of England. Nor did I know that there were slave labor camps on the island and members of their resistance died in more famous camps. I did not know about a lot of this history. And this is a book which makes the poignancy of the war every day. It roots it in food and books, and the ways these became luxuries and became community building rather than community destroying for some. The ache of sending children off island to places that were (they hoped) safer, and the lack of information both echo through the letters collected here. That decency might have been a characteristic of some Nazis, that religion might get entangled with class and lead to inhumane responses to moral complexity, that the sea is beautiful, isolating and dangerous, are all found here in amongst the characters who appear. That recovery from the war might take generations is also evident.
So: sometimes NY Times bestseller means, to me, schlock. Especially when the book seems in some ways to be marketed as chick lit. But this is emotionally wrenching in some ways with a focus on teh everyday in ways that chick lit can be without being chick lit at all. It's worth a read for a reminder that war -- includig those the US is involved in every day -- is wrenching and heartbreaking,
For another blog review, click here or try clicking here (for a site which focuses on Judaism). For an NPR interview with Annie Barrows, click here. Want to see an internet piece on an occupation era secet sociey newsletter regarding Hitler's death? Click here. for another book on a related topic, try here. On the slave labor in Guernsey per se, and concentration camps there as well as the sending of Gurnsey people to such campus elsewhere, try clicking here. For a first person narrative of liberation and related matters, try here.