The Cookbook Collector is a novel. And, it was a wonderful read. Authored by Allegra Goodman, the novel brings together environmetnal concerns, the dot.com/high tech bubble, September 11, and, yes, a cookbook collection. And this is not even to mention Jewish mysticism, family dynamics and family histories, a bit of romance, and . . . much more. I loved the way the book wove together various stories, without trivializing any of them, and the ways that the binaries of, say, book/computer, tree huggers/high tech, big sister/little sister, rich/poor, humanities/science or art/science and even maybe male/female get challenged as simplistic without the novel itself seeming simplistic at all. In many ways this is a book about lived experience, life -- you know. Life as lived and as thoughtfully or thoughtlessly lived. The characters are each more than a caricature (though there are moments when they seem to veer in that direction) and the places evoked are also wonderful in the ways they function as settings but feel almost like characters themselves.
Goodman is (according to the bio on her site) a child of academics, having a parent who teaches at Vanderbilt and another who was the Dean of Arts and Sciences there. This does not seem to lead her to be unduly sardonic about academia though there are a lot of graduate students in the book, and people who left academia for various reasons. A major character is a philosophy grad student. And, of course, Goodman has written more than a few novels. This one does, in fact, involve a cookbook collection -- inherited by someone who needs to sell them. They are found (ok, a tiny bit of a SPOILER ALERT) in various places in a kitchen (the stove, cabinets, everywhere) and are apparently an absolutely amazing find. The details provided by Goodman make clear she has done loads of homework -- without hitting readers over the head with too much didacticism. Both the collection as a whole and individual books descroibed in the novel are, for the collector who is a character and his "assistant" (the philosophy graduate student), over the top intriguing. Between the books themselves and the bits of ephemera contained therein, there is a bit of a mystery, and a lot of love. Not to mention some foodie fun.
The book made me think about where my cookbooks will go when I disappear from this earth. What, if anything, will strangers make of the ways I sometimes write in them and often drip food on them. In my case, of course, no one will really care -- but I love the fact that these people are curious about the prior owner(s). And, I love the intertwining of love of books, the language of food and cooking, and other matters.I liked the way the discoverers of the collection see it as a collection; one wonders if the heaps of books in my office and elsewhere areally do tell the story of a life. Hmmm. Meanwhile, I also came to think about the nature of collecting and collectors; I met someone recently who is a collector (most definitely not the same as a hoarder) and I have been thinking about how I get on themes for gifts and so collect by proxie sometimes, but do not think of myself as collecting some particular kind of item. I like a lot of things-- iron doorstops, bakelite napkin rings in the shape of animals and more, but I do not collect them. I wonder what the difference is between collectors and the rest of us. (And yes, I have lots of cookbooks, but still I do not think of myself as a collector. I have even more books if I count them up; but still, again, yet, I do not see myself as a collector.) Did you know there is a national association of collecting clubs? Who knew? (For more information, try here.) If you get into googling the way I do sometimes just to procrastinate, you too will discover a whole set of material on the psychology of collecting, ranging from Orhan Pamuk on the topic to the Frieze Foundation on the topic to. . . well, you know. Hmmm.
The book of course raises other topics. Bookstores, for example. Some book stores seem to have personalities like the one described in this novel -- stores where the collecting of the stock is as important as the selling of the stock, where one can wander and read and feel very very happy. This is indeed something I could identify with. There is no such bookstore in Geneva, NY. Alas. And, the book is also about food -- the words that make foods seem wonderful (or not).
Anyway, and also, this book is one of few I have read where September 11 appears as part of the historical backdrop -- and it feels ok. Not a memorial, just a huge event that shaped our lives in huge and varied ways, embedded in the everyday. (Did I say huge? Maybe also tiny.)
Here's Allegra Goodman's blog. And here's an interview with her on BookSlut. For the video obsessed, here's Goodman on the book and here she is at the National Book Awards for 2010. And, for the traditionalist in all of us, here's the NY Times book review of The Cookbook Collector.