On an impulse (she says), my partner bought me a delightful book when we were last at Ravine's. The book: Dan Barber's The Third Plate, subtitled Field Notes on the Future of Food. I read it while traveling, having held on to it for a time when I deserved a treat. And, I read it slowly.
Short review: Read this. It is smart, well written, hopeful, and intricate.
Longer review: I loved that this book began with Barber telling stories about a nearby farmer who I had reason to meet some time ago (when Alice Waters was in Seneca Falls) but that I do not know. And, I loved that my knowledge of my region grew and grew and grew. I also loved that Dan Barber writes well, including lovely sentences and lovely use of others' work. We have seen him on various documentaries (e.g., Chef's Table) and it was lovely to "meet" him again in a new way. (Here is a brief youtube related to Chef's Table.)
Longest review: Everything I wrote above is true, but requires reflection and elaboration, right? So here goes.
Let's begin with the local theme: Klaas Martens and Mary-Howell Martens are Lakeview Organic Grain. As I discovered by reading The Third Plate, their work as organic farmers began one day which might have been tragic: when spraying fields with various items one morning, Klaas discovered he could not move his arms. That day they say, was the start of their organic farming. Rather than enhancing their soils and managing their pests with chemical treatments, they began growing their soil. (For an article focused on the transition, click here.) That is, they focus on rotation crops and other strategies. (Click here for some more on this topic.) You can find them profiled on their website here, along with various others in their team. Located in Penn Yan, NY, on a farm that was his generationally (there is a longish and not always delightful family story involved here), the Martens' switch to organic and the success of their farm thereafter inspired many others around them. And, their need to vertically integrate led them to their own mill which serves many throughout the community.
But, no, Barber's book is not a profile of the Martens, though their focus on grain is why he initially looks to their work. Though focused on a close relation of farm to table, Barber is wrestling with what that means -- including which "engine" drives which and, what gets left out of such notions. One of the most ubiquitous products he uses is flour which, one day, he realizes is "dead" and has little to no taste. This leads to his ruminations -- and investigations -- into grains which takes him to Penn Yan, but also to the west coast, looking at a range of ways to move beyond industrial wheat.
Barber's ruminations are much wider, arranged as they are around the themes of. . . . . Hence, his discussions of fish and sustainability, of oceans and more. Hence his reflections on (Hudson Valley) foie gras (for a related Ted Talk click here) and on the farming they do at Blue Hill itself including the role of lambs and of pigs and of chickens. Is it possible to create foie gras without force-feeding? (At least one answer: yes.) What does one do when one impulsively serves high end food critics an unsustainable fish which "everyone" is no longer serving to try to help it make a come back? He reflects on historic heritage corn -- and the ways that heritage risks trying to preserve the past in amber (ask it were) and new varieties chosen in various ways -- in a discussion of tomatoes (and the horrifying late blight that has affected us all in upstate NY). His attention to location and to both/and seem to me to be a rich set of less rigid approaches to both dining now, cooking now, and creating a more vital future that is accessible not only to the wealthy. Barber listens -- and responds -- and seems to want to avoid simplistic responses. That is part of both his charm and his challenge,
The book is organized around the themes: soil; land; sea; seed. A reminder of the ways these interconnect, in part. A reminder of globalization. And, in each regard, a reminder that each of these is LIVING. His writing is so provocative that I ca, even now, some weeks later, imagine him standing in a trench looking at levels of soil, standing in a hotel hallway looking at huge long across depicting the roots beneath crops, and looking out from a roof onto the area of Spain from which that amazing jamon iberico comes. I know I have learned -- about the acorns those pigs eat, about the interweaving of culture and farming that creates that region, the ways that fish might be differently farmed, and more.
I have said it is well written. I have said there are sentences that moved me. I laughed on occasion and read aloud "Did you know, I asked." I recommend you read this too.
My goal now: a reservation at Blue Hill. We have been saying this for years. Really, Bibliochef: get off your duff.
And, I might read more that he has written. I know that my sense of what it means to eat and live responsibly has been affected by this book. All too rare.
And by the way, he has a website called The Third Plate. Ruth Reichl liked it. So did Al Gore. And so did I.