Christmas Dinner this past year -- that would be 2018 - was a challenge. (It was a month ago today! Time flies.) We just could not decide what we wanted - and with two of us many of the main dishes were kind of ruled out simply because they are hard to make in small doses (as it were)> We whiffle waffled -- and then I landed on Beef Wellington. At first this was because I had (a) encountered gluten free puff pastry; and (b) I thought I would make individual ones with filet mignon. I did not, of course, but that's where the adventure began. I also thought we could have horseradish sauce and green pepper sauce - we only had the latter and it was amazing.
So: here is what we did for the holiday! Combined with a few other of the recipes you have encountered this month - the main Christmas menu was Beef W (what I have come to call it since I am so very fond of it!), green peppercorn sauce, potato/leek gratin, and asparagus. And, of course, a lovely red wine.
First: Beef Wellington has always intrigued me. To be honest, I like filet mignon a lot and rarely have it except when out to dinner at a place where it is done well. That is, I only rarely cook it myself -- in part because I live with someone who prefers rib eye. I also have to admit that I have never ordered beef wellington, but somehow think of it as a romantic food. A bit of research (aka googling) has taught me that there are versions and then there are versions -- with and without fois gras, with and without truffle, and etcetera. I have also learned that Beef Wellington -- very often capitalized -- has a weird and mysterious lineage and there is no evidence of it having a relationship to any Duke of Wellington. Having said that, it is clear that wrapping meat in pastry has a long lineage with or without the name. I can suggest the wikipedia entry for a bit of detail - here.
I also want to note that the term duxelles fascinates me. Yes, I know it is a fancy way of saying mushrooms chopped very fine, with shallots, but (a) I have had them done extremely well -- and I suspect that has to do with both the quality of mushrooms and the amount of butter. And, (b) the term points us toward French cooking in some fancy way. I looked it up too. Here's a relevant recipe - though I particularly like the one with the recipe below. For more on what duxelles are and why we should all care, try here for the wikipedia overview. Unlike Beef Wellington, I think the naming history is clear. (I wonder if fund raisers could persuade people to give large quantities of money in order to name a food which eventually becomes classic and detached from historical reasons for acquiring the name?)
Finally, when anything involves prosciutto I say hurrah. And, at least many forms of Beef Wellington require prosciutto.
Second: Let's turn to the relevant recipe. I chose this one. Below I go over it and comment as appropriate (or, to be blunt, as I feel like it!). A few comments first: (a) I bought about 1.5 lbs of chateaubriand. Thats not what I asked for -- but that's what I got in terms of the name of the beef. I got it at Pittsford Wegs and I have to say it as over the top great beef. (Not cheap, but amazingly tasty.) (b) I made the quantity of duxelles called for i the recipe (which was for a larger piece of beef). (c) I used gluten free puff pastry -- and did a better job than when I made the carrot tart using the same puff pastry. There were still some issues (see below). (d) I loved how this looked, and was pretty damn impressed with myself and the help my partner gave.
Step 1: Make Duxelles
Ingredients: 3 pints of mushrooms (I used about a pound -- a 10 ounce of creminis and a 6 ounce or so of white mushrooms); I substituted a small onion for the shallots, I think; 4 cloves of garlic; some fresh thyme; 2 Tablespoons butter; @ Tablespoons olive oil; salt and pepper
Steps: In groups, put mushrooms (carefully cleaned), thyme, shallot (or onion) and garlic into food processor. Then, melt butter and olive oil in pan, add mushroom mixture, and cook on medium heat til dryish -- hte recipe says 8-10 minutes and it took well beyond that for me. The change is sort of sudden so pay attention.
Step 2: Organize the Prosciutto and Duxelles
I bought two packages of Wegman's prosciutto. I used about 3/4 of it. Here's how: (a) spread out about 1.5 foot of the saran wrap; (b) shingle the prosciutto into a rectangle (because you are eventually going to wrap the beef in it). (Because I did not do things quite right below -- or the measurements were off or something, I eventually used more prosciutto to wrap around the top side.)
Schmear the duxelles across the prosciutto in a thinnish layer. Salt and pepper it. Distribute some thyme leaves on it.
Step 3: Sear the Beef
First, tie the beef to get it into a compact tube. Sear the beef. All sides. Don't be a wimp. Let it cool just a tiny bit.
Step 4: Wrap Things Up
Remove strong and shmeer about @ tablespoons of dijon mustard on the beef. Situate the beef on the prosciutto and wrap it up as a log. I was surprised to discover that the prosciutto I put out was not quite enough and so I used extra to complete the wrapping.Wrap tightly! Tightly! Tightly! Once wrapped up in the plastic, stick in the fridge for a while - maybe 30 minutes.
Take it out of the fridge, and wrap it in puff pastry that you have rolled out into a rectangle. Be careful -- patch holes. Use egg wash. Top with coarse salt. I forgot to make slits on the top. You might want to do so. Position it in pan -- the recipe calls for a baking sheet, and I used a roasting pan -- perhaps in error. Be sure to put the seam down. I
Step 5: Cook the Darn Thing at 425 degrees for about 40 minutes. Use a thermometer (I bought a new one!) and move at about 125 degrees. (I over shot but rumor has it it was perfect.) Let it rest a bit before you slice it.
Step 6: Make Peppercorn Sauce.
Ingredients: The recipe calls for 2 tablespoons olive oil; 2 shallots, sliced; 2 cloves garlic, peeled and smashed; 3 sprigs fresh thyme, leaves only; 1 cup brandy; 1 box beef stock; 2 cups cream; 2 tablespoons grainy mustard; 1/2 cup green peppercorns in brine, drained, brine reserved; I used half of each item. The reason: the adventure of the peppercorns!
The Adventure of the Peppercorns: Wegmans is no longer perfect. Well, it has not been for ages - with declines in the knowledge level of staff, holiday decorations being for sale months ahead of any given holiday, and what not But: I was shocked that they do not carry green peppercorns. Not in Pittsford and perhaps no where. This drove us on line, but I discovered Wegman's lapse very close to Christmas. Thank goodness for friends, one of whom had green peppercorns. And delivered them to the door. She only had so many though, which explains the reason for halving the recipe.
Making the Sauce: Using same pan as the one in which you seared the beef, sauce shallots, garlic and thyme in olive oil; add brandy. And, TAKE OFF THE FLAME and turn the flame off. And, then light this on fire. I was amazed. It burned a long time, the flame was high, and it was fun. MY partner was not happy I did it without her watching. Anyway: I flambed! I am quite proud of it. Once the flame dies down, return to heat and add beef stock. reduce by half and then ignore the directions to strain out the solids. Add cream and mustard. reduce by half again. Add peppercorns. And voila! An amazing sauce
Step 7: Assemble and Eat Happily.
Once rested, slice the beef wellington, add sauce, and dine happily.
Third: How about an evaluation of the whole darn experience? I give this an A. I might even go so far as to say it was an A+. I served it with asparagus and a potato leek gratin. And, a lovely red wine.